To have Hernandez, the single thing forgotten out-of respectable consensual unions is legally binding approve of county

In some way my personal suggestion happens up against the very first and you may standard business from marriage, however, although we’re in support of matrimony, as it is suitable of males which generate laws and regulations for all those, we wish to silently believe people’s genuine state. Considering you to rules derives out-of fact, these people enjoys united here to write a composition and therefore wipes clean brand new errors of history and you may seeks a special highway for future years, [thus] it is important which they judiciously investigation this new criteria of one’s surroundings and you will reach the end that we now have some thing in the our everyday life as well as in our society that we can not in in any manner romantic the sight, that people must deal with valiantly. 51

Hernandez reasoned that simple courtroom sanction away from an intimate partnership you certainly will not truly the only research that any particular one is actually a proper and ethical resident

You will find started to the fresh Set-up to help you sparingly guard, on best of my element, the latest Cuban lady, the fresh partnered woman, the newest solitary girl, the new white girl, the latest black colored woman, female of all of the classes. I need to point out that there is a large number of Cuban women in hard and you may embarrassing facts, who are as the honorable and also as worth merit because the are almost every other ladies, that just since the woman is during the a free commitment, does not mean that individuals must look into her and her family unit members immoral. 52

By saying one good disjuncture existed anywhere between legislators’ beliefs and you can “personal fact,” Hernandez argued you to she is actually fighting getting Cubans who were perhaps not aren’t considered to be type sexual propriety and, ergo, was basically unjustly disenfranchised

Twenty-a couple of out from the 60-half dozen Installation participants going to the brand new training voted so you’re able to approve Hernandez’s proposal. Most of individuals who voted within the favor reasoned that it perform assist males into the consensual unions to meet up with an identical requirements and you will requirements you to definitely partnered guys was in fact bound to meet and you can, for this reason, do include every woman and children. For example, progressive Installation user Capablanca contended one to “although it [Hernandez’s modification] seems paradoxical, from getting…a strike into relationship, it is actually a shelter from it.” 53 The guy said, “When males remember that they are responsible for people that have which he has good consensual commitment and for the people one to result because of these totally free unions, they cannot practice consensual unions however in relationship.” 54 Capablanca portrayed guys just like the nearly inherently irresponsible, and implied that ladies requisite Condition defense against him or her. Others echoed their rationale.

Although not, most Set-up participants, progressives and traditionals, balked within Hernandez’s tip, arguing that it was not that lead in order to popular progress and you will carry out offer legal rights and rights so you’re able to undeserving, depraved customers. Traditional Installation user Cortina contributed a beneficial spirited struggle against Hernandez’s suggestion, shaping their dissent because a battle to own modernity, advances, and you will society. The guy said that an excellent constitutional guarantee to take on consensual unions similar to legal marriages would generally upload Cuba out-of with the an appropriate path divergent away from that “all of the gentle regions in the world” and you can “destroy…the fresh matrimonial program, and then make [it] entirely useless.” 55 Cortina prophesied, “In the event it amendment was indeed accepted, we may write a massive dilemma within the judge married life, and then we do take the consequences of your governmental revolution and therefore you will find just lived thanks to, so you’re able to sectors in our sentimental and you can relatives existence, [sectors] which don’t need to end up being switched throughout the major and perturbing manner in which was advised.” 56 For Cortina, this new 1933 wave was a political wave, and you may further reform should merely apply to government: Social points should be left by yourself.